Shut Up & Play The Hits
review
Reading Michael Lewis on government is like watching Michael Jordan take batting practice at Comiskey Park.
His forte is telling a great story from concepts that should bore you. For example, labor market arbitrage in Moneyball and complex financial instruments in The Big Short. But his new book Blockers, another one about bad government—despite being the journalism that is sorely needed in this moment—is not what I particularly want.
Blockers is about civil servants who did their best to protect their work and workplaces amid the chaos of DOGE and the Trump era. The book is populated with intelligent and competent workers who fall on their swords in the name of the common good, rather than pledging fealty to the President.
A good book summary from p. 7:
The story to tell about Trump's first term was all about the price of ignorance and the risk of radical neglect. The story to tell about the second term was different. It was about all those people and roles in and around the United States government once taken for granted and now gone. The second Trump administration was a bit like a meteor strike or some massive environmental shift. It killed off entire species and made room for new ones.
Lewis's best narratives feed into the very sellable dream of being ridiculously right when everyone else is horribly wrong. But there is no winning in this situation. Politics is a game of attrition. If we had a winning moment, it was the midterms, and even that is the start of a long two years.
Yes, it is the duty of journalists to bear witness to this administration. And Lewis is among the best nonfiction writers of our time, certainly of the aughts. My question is whether he should leave this sort of work to the people who are the best at it and stay in his lane. And if our government sucks, what good will it do to see a hypothetical movie about it starring Austin Abrams as a young, brusque DOGE contractor and Amy Adams as a tough but lovable IRS lawyer? Is this a thing our world needs?
Literature, fiction or non-, shouldn't live and die by the broccoli argument (not Scalia's, your mother's). I just want to feel smart and be entertained.
What's missing from Blockers are stakes and payoff. Under this administration, there is no positive payoff coming. The Big Short and Moneyball are addictive because they attach long-simmering stakes to zero-sum contests: iconoclastic trades and a season’s worth of baseball games, respectively. Lewis's publicity materials focus on character and how good he is at explaining things, but I don't think that's what makes him a generationally great writer. Really, he takes betting, and the wonderful, morally dubious feeling that it elicits, and imbues it with stakes, hooking you faster than a drunk cigarette on a night out.
My favorite chapter is the last one. It reads like a mystery thriller set at an office park: a whodunnit about the firing of a man "who helped uncover the mysteries of cystic fibrosis."
Yes, in saying all this, I am breaking the golden rule of book reviewing by yelling at the writer for having written the book they wrote, but Lewis is special. He is a literary celebrity. He appears on the same TV talk shows as actors. He can pretty much do as he pleases. It's hard for me to not wish he had written a different, more entertaining book, especially since this is his fourth recent book on government, if you include a book of essays he edited.
A small point about the future of journalism: at a recent conference, Arvind Narayanan, a computer scientist at Princeton University, made some predictions.
Narayanan expects chatbots to become the default place to settle factual questions. Take that a step further, to personalized agents that brief us on relevant stories and data, and what’s left for humans is mostly spinning a good yarn. To my mind, Michael Lewis is the best example of this kind of journalist. Maybe we need Lewis, and others like him, to write interesting stories about civics and other things few people care about.
Which cuts against everything I’ve just argued. But will people still read these stories?
Earlier this month I attended a promotional event where, among many topics, Lewis spoke about book characters the way a casting agent does for a Hollywood film.
Lewis was colorful in person. He wore a purple sweater, whitish jeans, some kind of smart watch, pink socks, and Hoka sneakers. On the topic of his socks, he has a metaphor for describing a writing subject that excites him and it has forever lodged itself in my brain: a good subject "makes [your] socks go up and down" which I assume refers to bouncing one's knees while typing away. He uses this same metaphor in his earlier book, the collection of essays called Who Is Government? In it, he provides his rationale for publishing books on this subject: because they sell.
Lewis talked with his hands. He mentioned that he had already done more than 20 of these promotional appearances for Blockers alone. You could tell. While he was not boring, I couldn't help but feel like I was witnessing a rehearsed performance. He seemed restless as he tested his interlocutor, a PBS host.
It was mildly exciting to see Lewis in person, but it reminded me of the way you feel about finally seeing a band you loved as a kid that no longer figures in your imagination the way it once did.
TL;DR: It's a shame to watch Lewis use his talent in a civically responsible way.